Objection · 04
Pistachio's 'overall progress, not individual stats' is more humane.
Validate
Respect the framing. Pistachio's privacy posture on Presence is well-executed and the historical privacy problems of insider-threat tools are real.
Reframe
Quite the opposite is the architectural truth. Cohort-only reporting means everyone gets the same intervention regardless of their real situation. Individual risk profiling, done right, is more humane than uniform treatment.
Say
Moxso profiles individual risk precisely to avoid punishing everyone the same way. Context-aware intervention is more humane than uniform broadcast.
Proof · Regulation
NIS2 needs proof that controls are working at role level — not at organisation level. Cohort-only reporting cannot show whether the right people's behaviour changed.